A pub showing the football tonight. Can I book a table?
What ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini answered when asked this in New York cafes and bars on 2026-10-26, with web search on. Below are the places named, who named each one, and the direct link where the place has one.
| Place | Named by | Direct link |
|---|---|---|
| Smithfield Hall | Claude with its own site Gemini with its own site | smithfieldnyc.com |
| Brickyard Craft Kitchen & Bar | ChatGPT with its own site | brickyardbarnyc.com |
| Carraghers Pub & Restaurant | Gemini with its own site | carraghersnyc.com |
| City Coffee & Bar | ChatGPT with its own site | citycoffeebar.com |
| Jones Wood Foundry | Claude with its own site | joneswoodfoundry.com |
| The Football Factory at Legends not in the index | Gemini with its own site | footballfactoryny.com |
| The Three Monkeys | ChatGPT with its own site | thethreemonkeysbar.com |
| Football Factory at Legends not in the index | Claude by name | no link given |
How this is read
Each assistant was asked each question once, with web search on, for up to three places and the link to each one's own website. Names are read from the answer and matched against the index. Any link between one name and the next belongs to that place. "With its own site" means the assistant linked the place's own website. "Through a marketplace" or "a directory" means it linked a listing instead, and "by name" means it gave no link. The direct links come from the Direct Index's own scan of the place's site. The assistant didn't supply them.
Every question for New York cafes and bars · Where assistants send people in New York cafes and bars.