# The Scotch Malt Whisky Society: Agent-Direct Score F (0%)

Site: http://www.thediningroomedinburgh.co.uk/
Report: https://directindex.org/r/thediningroomedinburgh.co.uk
Scanned: 2026-10-14 (Provisional: the assistant citation check still to come; the hatched part of the bar is not measured yet.)
The Scotch Malt Whisky Society's website could not be reached by the scanner on 2026-10-14 (TimeoutError: The operation was aborted due to timeout). Rescans are free.
AI assistants cannot open the website of The Scotch Malt Whisky Society, so they rely on what other sites say about it.

## Direct links
- Phone: +44 131 220 2044

## What to fix first
- **The site could not be read at all.** The server did not answer requests coming from Cloudflare's network. A hosting firewall may be blocking it.

## Already right
- Nothing.

## Where it stands
419 of 427 in Edinburgh. Top 98% of the sites scanned in this index.

| What the top tenth of the index does | Top 10% | This site |
|---|---|---|
| Take bookings or orders on their own domain | 100% | no |
| Publish the menu or price list as HTML | 72% | no |
| Let AI crawlers in (no edge block, no robots.txt block) | 95% | yes |
| Structured data with address, phone and hours | 70% | no |
| Have an llms.txt | 23% | no |

Nearest places in the index: Noto (D, 52 m, https://directindex.org/r/notoedinburgh.co.uk); Dusit (D, 52 m, https://directindex.org/r/dusit.co.uk); Café Saint Honoré (A, 60 m, https://directindex.org/r/cafesthonore.com); Greenwoods (B, 82 m, https://directindex.org/r/greenwoods.eu); Yarn (B, 89 m, https://directindex.org/r/yaranrestaurant.co.uk); Côte Brasserie (B, 96 m, https://directindex.org/r/cote.co.uk); Rosa's Thai Cafe (A, 120 m, https://directindex.org/r/rosasthai.com); Urban Angel (A, 129 m, https://directindex.org/r/urban-angel.co.uk); Chez Jules (D, 130 m, https://directindex.org/r/chezjulesbistro.com); papii (D, 132 m, https://directindex.org/r/papii.co.uk).

## What assistants answer
Not asked yet. Assistants are asked about the top-ranked businesses in each city index, and about every claimed business the moment it is claimed; claim this page to be included.

## Businesses like The Scotch Malt Whisky Society in Edinburgh

| Group | Sites | Avg score | A or B | This site |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Businesses of the same kind in Edinburgh | 427 | 56% | 45% | 0% |

The best of the businesses of the same kind in Edinburgh: Minami (A 100%, https://directindex.org/r/minami-sushi.co.uk); Rishi's Indian Aroma (A 100%, https://directindex.org/r/rishis.restaurant); Chaskaa (A 96.3%, https://directindex.org/r/chaskaaindian.co.uk); McLarens (A 96.3%, https://directindex.org/r/mclarensonthecorner.co.uk); The Radhuni (A 96.3%, https://directindex.org/r/theradhuni.co.uk).

## The direct record
What agents get for The Scotch Malt Whisky Society, as JSON: https://directindex.org/api/direct/thediningroomedinburgh.co.uk
- Book: none on record
- Order: none on record
- Menu: none on record
- Hours: none on record
- Phone: +44 131 220 2044

## Score breakdown
| Component | Points | Available |
|---|---|---|
| Reachable | 0 | 25 |
| Readable | 0 | 25 |
| Actionable | 0 | 30 |
| Cited | 0 | 0 (the assistant citation check: pending) |

## Agent readiness (Cloudflare)
Not measured for this scan.
- JSON-LD for the business: no

Keep watching this business (https://directindex.org/r/thediningroomedinburgh.co.uk/plan): the assistants asked again every month, with what changed; 2 EUR a month or 19 EUR a year.
Deep report: https://directindex.org/r/thediningroomedinburgh.co.uk/deep. Ten questions the way people ask, each assistant's full answer, the eight nearest similar places, the fix plan and a PDF: 5 EUR, one-off. Reading and scanning stay free; these few euros pay for the questions sent to the assistants and for the servers.
Methodology: https://directindex.org/methodology · Rescan now: https://directindex.org/scan?url=thediningroomedinburgh.co.uk&force=1