# Creel Caught by Gary Maclean: Agent-Direct Score D (49.2%) Site: http://www.creelcaught.com/ Report: https://directindex.org/r/creelcaught.com Scanned: 2026-10-21 (Provisional, with the action test and the assistant citation check still to come. The hatched part of the bar isn't measured yet.) Creel Caught by Gary Maclean is hard for agents to use. An AI assistant can open Creel Caught by Gary Maclean's website. It can read what Creel Caught by Gary Maclean offers. It can't find a link to book or order online. ## Direct links - Menu: https://creelcaught.com/creel-caught-menu/ - Address: Bonnie & Wild 415 - 417 St James Cresent , EH1 3AE, Edinburgh ## Nearby, also direct Places near Creel Caught by Gary Maclean that take a booking or an order on their own website, with no marketplace in between. - Cafe Royal (180 m): https://directindex.org/r/caferoyaledinburgh.com - White Horse (640 m): https://directindex.org/r/whitehorseoysterbar.co.uk - Mussel Inn (670 m): https://directindex.org/r/mussel-inn.com - Cadiz (780 m): https://directindex.org/r/cadizedinburgh.co.uk - Coast and Creel (1.6 km): https://directindex.org/r/coastandcreel.co.uk ## What to fix first - **No structured data for the business.** (+15 points) Add schema.org JSON-LD for the business (Restaurant, LocalBusiness or the closest type, with name, address, telephone and openingHoursSpecification, plus servesCuisine and acceptsReservations). Every assistant reads this block first, and the fix kit below has it filled in. Guide: https://directindex.org/guides/structured-data-restaurant - **No booking or ordering link on the website.** (+15 points) There's no link on the site for an agent to follow. If you take bookings or orders through a platform, link to it from the site so agents can find it. Add a booking or ordering page on your own domain. Guide: https://directindex.org/guides/book-direct-on-your-own-website - **No llms.txt.** (no points, but worth doing) Optional for now and cheap to add. It's a short text file that describes the business for language models. Guide: https://directindex.org/guides/llms-txt-for-a-business ## Fix kit: What to paste Structured data (JSON-LD). Paste it as one block in the page's head, or in the builder's custom code box. Change anything that's wrong. ```html ``` llms.txt. Save as /llms.txt at the root of the site. ``` # Creel Caught by Gary Maclean > local business (seafood) in Bonnie & Wild 415 - 417 St James Cresent , EH1 3AE, Edinburgh, Edinburgh. ## Book or order directly - Menu: https://creelcaught.com/creel-caught-menu/ ## About - Website: http://www.creelcaught.com/ - This file follows llms.txt (https://llmstxt.org): a short plain-text description for language models. ``` ## Already right - **robots.txt lets AI crawlers in.** No rule blocks the main AI user agents. - **AI crawlers get the page.** GPTBot, ClaudeBot and PerplexityBot all got a normal response. - **Menu or price list is an HTML page.** Agents can read the items and prices. ## Where it stands 589 of 930 in Edinburgh. Top 63% of the sites scanned in this index. | What the top 10% of the index does | Top 10% | This site | |---|---|---| | Take bookings or orders on their own domain | 99% | no | | Publish the menu or price list as HTML | 75% | yes | | Let AI crawlers in (no block at the server or in robots.txt) | 95% | yes | | Structured data with address, phone and hours | 57% | no | | Have an llms.txt | 22% | no | Nearest places with a similar menu: Cafe Royal (B, 176 m, https://directindex.org/r/caferoyaledinburgh.com); White Horse (C, 636 m, https://directindex.org/r/whitehorseoysterbar.co.uk); Mussel Inn (B, 673 m, https://directindex.org/r/mussel-inn.com); Ondine (B, 741 m, https://directindex.org/r/ondinerestaurant.co.uk); Cadiz (B, 784 m, https://directindex.org/r/cadizedinburgh.co.uk); Sea Fish Industry Authority (D, 1150 m, https://directindex.org/r/seafish.org); Dulse Seafood & Wine (F, 1370 m, https://directindex.org/r/dulse.co.uk); Coast and Creel (B, 1575 m, https://directindex.org/r/coastandcreel.co.uk); The Ship On The Shore (B, 2687 m, https://directindex.org/r/theshipontheshore.co.uk); Fin & Grape (A, 2742 m, https://directindex.org/r/finandgrape.com). ## What assistants answer The assistants haven't been asked about this business yet. They're asked about the top-ranked businesses in each city index, and about any business as soon as it's claimed. Claim this page to be included. The assistants were asked 13 everyday questions about Edinburgh and named 62 places. Creel Caught by Gary Maclean wasn't one of them. See who was named: https://directindex.org/city/edinburgh/recommended Compared with its peers: Sites built with WordPress 57% (28% A or B, 145483 sites); This site 49.2%. See what an AI agent reads on this site: https://directindex.org/r/creelcaught.com/agent-view ## Businesses like Creel Caught by Gary Maclean in Edinburgh | Group | Sites | Avg score | A or B | This site | |---|---|---|---|---| | Businesses of the same kind in Edinburgh | 930 | 55% | 39% | 49.2% | | Sites built with WordPress in Edinburgh | 287 | 68% | 55% | 49.2% | The best of the sites built with WordPress in Edinburgh: Minami (A 100%, https://directindex.org/r/minami-sushi.co.uk); Chaskaa (A 96.3%, https://directindex.org/r/chaskaaindian.co.uk); McLarens (A 96.3%, https://directindex.org/r/mclarensonthecorner.co.uk); The Radhuni (A 96.3%, https://directindex.org/r/theradhuni.co.uk); Dhaba 36 (A 95.4%, https://directindex.org/r/dhaba36.co.uk). With the two fixes above (No structured data for the business; No booking or ordering link on the website), the score would be about 95.4%. That would be 9th of 930 in Edinburgh, up from 589th. ## The direct record What agents get for Creel Caught by Gary Maclean, as JSON: https://directindex.org/api/direct/creelcaught.com - Book: none on record - Order: none on record - Menu: https://creelcaught.com/creel-caught-menu/ (html_page; from the scan) - Hours: none on record - Phone: none on record - Stable links that count: https://directindex.org/go/creelcaught.com/menu ## Can an agent transact? Measured, not scored (the score stays at spec v1.0). - UCP profile (/.well-known/ucp, Google and Shopify's Universal Commerce Protocol): no - ACP discovery document (/.well-known/acp.json, OpenAI and Stripe's Agentic Commerce Protocol): no - MCP server card (/.well-known/mcp/server-card.json): no - Ordering vendor that takes agent orders (Square, Toast, or a vendor whose terms allow agents): no ## Score breakdown | Component | Points | Available | |---|---|---| | Reachable | 25 | 25 | | Readable | 7 | 25 | | Actionable | 0 | 15 (the action test: pending) | | Cited | 0 | 0 (the assistant citation check: pending) | ## Agent readiness (Cloudflare) Level 1 of 5, Basic Web Presence. Cloudflare's report: https://isitagentready.com/creelcaught.com - Link headers on the homepage: no (how: https://isitagentready.com/.well-known/agent-skills/link-headers/SKILL.md) - sitemap.xml: yes - AI bot rules in robots.txt: yes - Content Signals in robots.txt: no (how: https://isitagentready.com/.well-known/agent-skills/content-signals/SKILL.md) - Markdown on Accept: text/markdown: no (how: https://isitagentready.com/.well-known/agent-skills/markdown-negotiation/SKILL.md) - llms.txt: no (how: https://isitagentready.com/.well-known/agent-skills/llms-txt/SKILL.md) - API catalog (RFC 9727): no (how: https://isitagentready.com/.well-known/agent-skills/api-catalog/SKILL.md) - MCP server card: no (how: https://isitagentready.com/.well-known/agent-skills/mcp-server-card/SKILL.md) - A2A agent card: no (how: https://isitagentready.com/.well-known/agent-skills/a2a-agent-card/SKILL.md) - Agent Skills index: no (how: https://isitagentready.com/.well-known/agent-skills/agent-skills/SKILL.md) - OAuth or OIDC discovery: no (how: https://isitagentready.com/.well-known/agent-skills/oauth-discovery/SKILL.md) - OAuth protected resource metadata: no (how: https://isitagentready.com/.well-known/agent-skills/oauth-protected-resource/SKILL.md) - auth.md: no (how: https://isitagentready.com/.well-known/agent-skills/auth-md/SKILL.md) - Web Bot Auth key directory: no (how: https://isitagentready.com/.well-known/agent-skills/web-bot-auth/SKILL.md) - ARD capability manifest: no (how: https://isitagentready.com/.well-known/agent-skills/ard/SKILL.md) - DNS-AID records: no (how: https://isitagentready.com/.well-known/agent-skills/dns-aid/SKILL.md) - WebMCP tools on the page: no (how: https://isitagentready.com/.well-known/agent-skills/webmcp/SKILL.md) - JSON-LD for the business: no Keep watching this business (https://directindex.org/r/creelcaught.com/plan): the assistants are asked again every month, and you see what changed. 2 EUR a month or 19 EUR a year. Deep report: https://directindex.org/r/creelcaught.com/deep. Ten questions phrased the way people ask them, each assistant's full answer, the eight nearest similar places, the fix plan and a PDF. 5 EUR, paid once. Reading and scanning stay free. These few euros pay for the questions sent to the assistants and for the servers. Methodology: https://directindex.org/methodology ยท Rescan now: https://directindex.org/scan?url=creelcaught.com&force=1